Predatory Lending: Federal Rules and Your Rights
How federal law defines predatory lending: HOEPA, the ability-to-repay rule, and the Military Lending Act, plus where to complain and what states regulate.
Predatory lending is not a single statute. It is a label for a set of loan practices that federal and state law address piece by piece. The practices share a structure: the borrower receives less value than the loan’s cost implies, the terms conceal or defer the real burden, and the lender or broker is paid at the point of sale in a way that rewards putting the borrower into that loan. The federal rules that reach these practices are mostly disclosure, underwriting and cost-threshold rules, and they apply to specific categories of loans and lenders. Knowing which category a loan falls into determines which rights attach.
The practices the term describes
Loan flipping is repeated refinancing of the same debt, each time with new fees rolled into the principal. The borrower’s balance grows while the lender or broker collects a new set of closing costs. Equity stripping is lending against a home on terms the borrower’s income cannot sustain, so that a default transfers the accumulated equity to the lender through foreclosure. Packing is adding products the borrower did not ask for, such as credit insurance or a club membership, into the loan amount or the payment. Steering is directing a borrower to a higher-cost product than the one they qualify for, often because the broker is paid more for it. A balloon trap is a loan with a large payment due at the end, underwritten on the assumption that the borrower will refinance before it comes due, on terms that may not be available then.
None of these is illegal in itself. The legal question is whether the specific loan violated a disclosure requirement, an underwriting requirement, a cost threshold, or a state lending or usury statute.
HOEPA: the high-cost mortgage trigger
The Home Ownership and Equity Protection Act, 15 U.S.C. Sec. 1639, and its implementing rule at Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.32, impose extra requirements on mortgages that cross defined cost thresholds. The thresholds are stated as points and fees measured against the loan amount, and as a comparison of the loan’s rate to a benchmark average prime offer rate published by the Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council. The specific figures change; the current ones are published in Regulation Z and in the CFPB’s periodic threshold adjustments, and any page quoting a fixed number will be out of date.
A loan that is a high-cost mortgage under these rules carries restrictions on prepayment penalties, on balloon payments, on negative amortization, and on financing points and fees. It also requires the borrower to receive homeownership counseling before closing. The statute and regulation define which loans are covered; a mortgage that does not cross the thresholds is outside HOEPA even if its terms are unfavorable.
Ability to repay under 12 CFR 1026.43
The ability-to-repay rule, at 12 CFR 1026.43, requires a creditor to make a reasonable, good-faith determination that a consumer can repay a residential mortgage loan before making it. The rule sets out underwriting factors the creditor must consider, including income, assets, employment, debt obligations and credit history. It creates a category of qualified mortgages that carry a presumption of compliance, with conditions on points and fees, loan features and term.
The practical effect is that a loan made without regard to whether the borrower could repay it is a potential violation of the rule, and the borrower’s remedy depends on whether the loan was a qualified mortgage and on the statute of limitations. This is a claim that generally requires a lawyer to evaluate.
The Military Lending Act, 10 U.S.C. Sec. 987
The Military Lending Act caps the military annual percentage rate on certain consumer credit extended to covered borrowers, which includes active-duty servicemembers and their dependents. It also restricts mandatory arbitration and requires specific disclosures. The definition of covered credit and the calculation of the military APR are set by the Department of Defense’s implementing regulation, 32 CFR Part 232. The MLA applies to a defined set of products and borrowers; a loan to a civilian is outside it.
Where the FDCPA does and does not reach
A common error is treating the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act as a general remedy against the original lender. The FDCPA, 15 U.S.C. Sec. 1692 et seq., governs debt collectors, generally third parties collecting a debt owed to another, and it largely does not govern an original creditor collecting its own debt. A borrower who believes the original lender behaved unlawfully needs a different statute, often the Truth in Lending Act (15 U.S.C. Sec. 1601 et seq.), HOEPA, the ability-to-repay rule, or a state consumer protection statute. The distinction matters because it determines who can be sued and under what section.
What moves the cost of a loan, and where the figure is published
The cost of a mortgage or consumer loan is driven by the rate, the points and fees, the term, whether the rate is fixed or adjustable, whether there is a prepayment penalty, and whether products are financed into the principal. Federal law requires the annual percentage rate and the finance charge to be disclosed on the Truth in Lending disclosure, so the current cost of a specific offer is on that document. Benchmark rates and the HOEPA thresholds are published by the CFPB and the Federal Reserve. No fixed rate or fee should be treated as current; the disclosed figures for the loan in hand are the ones that matter.
State law and where the rules diverge
Usury limits, licensing requirements for lenders and brokers, and state unfair or deceptive practices statutes vary by state. Some states cap interest on certain loan sizes; others regulate by license category. A loan that complies with federal disclosure rules can still violate a state usury or licensing statute, and the reverse. The reader needs to look up the licensing regulator for the lender type in their state, the state usury statute, and the state attorney general’s consumer protection division. State statutes of limitation for claims also vary and determine how long a borrower has to bring an action.
Where a complaint goes
Complaints about a mortgage lender or servicer can be filed with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, which accepts complaints at consumerfinance.gov/complaint. Complaints about a state-licensed lender or broker can go to the state regulator that licenses that entity. The state attorney general’s office handles consumer protection complaints and can bring enforcement actions. For servicemembers, the Department of Defense and the servicemember’s branch of service have channels for Military Lending Act issues. A complaint does not itself recover money; it creates a record and may prompt an examination or enforcement referral.
When the stakes require a lawyer
A foreclosure, a loan in default, or a claim involving a large sum is the point to get actual legal help. Federal and state claims have filing deadlines, and the remedies differ by statute. This page describes how the rules work; it does not advise on a specific loan.
Sources
Common questions
What is the difference between predatory lending and a bad loan?
Predatory lending refers to practices that violate specific legal requirements, such as HOEPA's high-cost mortgage rules, the ability-to-repay rule, or state usury and licensing laws. A loan with unfavorable terms is not automatically predatory; the question is whether a statute was violated.
Does the FDCPA apply to the original lender?
Generally no. The FDCPA governs third-party debt collectors, not an original creditor collecting its own debt. Claims against an original lender usually arise under the Truth in Lending Act, HOEPA, the ability-to-repay rule, or state law.
What is loan flipping?
Loan flipping is repeated refinancing of the same debt, with new fees added each time. It is not illegal by itself, but it can violate disclosure or underwriting rules depending on the loan and the state.
Where can I complain about a predatory loan?
Complaints can be filed with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau at consumerfinance.gov/complaint, with the state regulator that licenses the lender, or with the state attorney general. Servicemembers have additional channels under the Military Lending Act.
Do state laws on predatory lending differ?
Yes. Usury limits, licensing requirements, and unfair or deceptive practices statutes vary by state, and so do statutes of limitation. A loan that complies with federal rules can still violate state law.
Read next
- The Truth in Lending Act: What It Requires TILA (15 U.S.C. Sec. 1601 et seq.) and Regulation Z require lenders to disclose credit costs before you are bound. What the law covers and what it does not.
- Wage Garnishment Limits: Federal Caps and State Rules Federal law caps what an ordinary creditor can take from a paycheck and many states cap it lower. The stricter limit is the one that applies.
- Equal Credit Opportunity Act: Rights and Limits The Equal Credit Opportunity Act and Regulation B bar credit discrimination on specified grounds. Who is covered, what creditors may consider, where to complain.
- Federal vs Private Student Loans: How They Differ Federal student loans are set by statute; private loans are contracts. Compare repayment, default, discharge, and co-signer rules before borrowing.
- 50/30/20 Budget: How the Split Works and Where It Fails Learn the 50/30/20 budget rule: how the split works, what counts in each bucket, and why it fails for high-rent cities or irregular income. See alternatives.